The Best Way to Book a Villa on St. John

August 25, 2017

When you come to St. John, do you usually stay in a hotel or a villa? Many people new to the island first start off in hotels, then later branch out to renting private villas, enjoying the more personal experience. Staying in a villa allows visitors to enjoy more space, more amenities (hello, kitchen!), and to feel like they’re actually living on the island for a week or so.


Villas on St. John come in a wide range of options, from the ultra luxurious, to the more relaxed, tropical bungalow-feel.


But knowing where to look and how to go about renting a villa on St. John can get confusing, even overwhelming at times.


For many vacation planners, searching AirBnB or VRBO was the best way they could determine to find a St. John vacation rental. Both companies have hundreds and hundreds of listings to browse. And when you find something you’re interested in booking – you simply click, click, click to make an online inquiry/booking. But there’s a dark little secret that neither site wants you to know.


Clicking and booking through one of these mega travel sites costs money. First off, it costs the villa owner commission and transaction fees that they pay to VRBO and AirBnB. But what many people are waking up to is that both sites also charge guests a “service fee” each time they book online.


How much do they charge? Well, that depends on the rental, the number of guests, the time of year, and each site’s fee algorithm. What we can tell you is that VRBO charges, on average, 12% of your booking with a maximum charge of $599 per booking. AirBnB, the industry darling, charges between 12%-20%+ with no cap on the service fee (aka booking fee). We’ve seen AirBnB service fees in the thousands of dollars for luxury St. John rentals!


Thankfully, now, finding the perfect place to stay on St. John has never been easier…


Happily, St. John has a new Book Direct vacation rental site, St. John Villa Rentals. The site doesn’t charge owners a commission, and it doesn’t charge guests a “service fee.” There’s no middleman/woman, so there’s no middleman/woman fees!


Here’s what we love about this Book Direct site:


  • They have a huge inventory to browse – currently over 340 listings!
  • You can book directly regardless of your travel style: condos, cottages, villas, even Westin St John resort rentals!
  • It has an easy to use search function – sort by rate, amenities, location, etc.
  • You have the ability to communicate directly with a rental owner or manager.
  • You save hundreds and hundreds of dollars in fees!
  • They have exclusive discount offers.
  • They have a Villa Directory, so if you know the name of a villa, you can find it quickly.
  • Their Quick Find Pages include: beachfront rentals, resorts, B&Bs, Grande Bay Resort, Lavender Hill, and Gallows Point Resort.


Check out the site and start planning your future trip – we can’t wait to see you on Honeymoon Beach!

Please join our monthly newsletter!

You May Also Like


Three people are in a yellow ocean kayak

Cas Cay Kayak, Hike & Snorkeling Ecotour

A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. Thomas

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

3 Hours

Embark on an exclusive morning adventure through the serene beauty of Cas Cay, where tranquil mangroves, vibrant marine life, and breathtaking volcanic vistas await—discover this hidden gem with knowledgeable guides.

A group of people are walking down a path towards the ocean.
A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. John

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

3 Hours

Hike & Beach Adventure Tour: Discover Honeymoon Beach on St. John

Looking to pack a BIG experience into a short amount of time? Then we’ve got just the adventure for you! This tour is designed for groups of 4 or more.

A group of people are swimming with sea turtles in the ocean.

Swim alongside graceful Hawksbill and Green Sea Turtles in the crystal-clear waters of St. Croix on this unforgettable guided snorkel tour. Explore vibrant coral reefs and encounter diverse marine life with expert guides ensuring a safe and memorable experience. Perfect for all skill levels, this unique adventure offers an up-close look at St. Croix’s stunning underwater world—an experience you’ll never forget.

A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. Croix

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

1.5 Hours

St. Croix's Best Snorkeling with Sea Turtles

Other Blogs


A sea turtle is swimming in the ocean with the sun shining through the water.
February 27, 2026
Find the best places to see sea turtles on St John in the US Virgin Islands, including Maho Bay, Francis Bay, and local tips for calm-water snorkeling experience.
A sea turtle is swimming in the ocean near a coral reef.
February 20, 2026
Discover the best places to swim with sea turtles in St. Thomas and St. John in the US Virgin Islands, plus tips on timing, locations, and turtle etiquette.
By Chrissann Nickel February 19, 2026
If you’ve been to St. John in the US Virgin Islands, you’ve likely encountered the wild donkeys around the island. Whether they approached you on the beach, strolled up to your Jeep’s window, or clip-clopped alongside you while shopping in Mongoose Junction, you were likely charmed by the presence of such a surprising farm animal on our little island. Because we’ve been posting a bunch of fun donkey videos lately over on our Facebook and Instagram accounts (if you’re not already following us, be sure to go and join in on the fun!), we thought we’d share a few fun details about the island’s donkey population.
A beach with the words merry christmas written in the sand
January 30, 2026
Learn what to expect when visiting the Virgin Islands during Christmas: festive events, island traditions, warm weather, and travel tips for the holidays.
By Chrissann Nickel January 29, 2026
The US Virgin Islands are a great place for both beginner and experienced snorkelers. The waters tend to be calm, clear, and warm year round, and there are many places where you can see an abundance of reef and marine life in relatively shallow waters. We love helping visitors experience the magic of the underwater world, and we have guided snorkeling tours and snorkel gear rentals available on all three islands: St. Thomas , St. John , and St. Croix . In order to best appreciate our waters and have a wonderful time while you’re “under the sea,” here are a few USVI snorkeling safety tips to keep in mind:
There are many boats in the water with mountains in the background
January 23, 2026
Trying to choose between St. Thomas vs St. John? See which island fits your trip style based on cost, vibe, logistics, and activities before you book your trip.
A group of people are standing on rocks near the ocean.
December 30, 2025
Not sure whether to rent water sports gear or book a guided tour? Learn the pros and cons of each to choose the best Virgin Islands experience.
By Chrissann Nickel December 24, 2025
Here’s a hot take I have for the US Virgin Islands: Everyone should take a guided snorkel tour at least a couple of times, no matter how many times they’ve been snorkeling here before. I know, I know… you’ve already snorkeled here. Why would going with a guide change anything when you already know how to snorkel? Why do you need someone to accompany you when you already have a fish identification card and rented snorkel gear so you can go by yourself?
By Chrissann Nickel November 20, 2025
Unless you don’t use social media and/or haven’t done any research about visiting the US Virgin Islands, you’ve likely heard of and seen plenty of pictures and videos of Lime Out , the floating taco bar off the island of St. John. It’s hard to miss all of their amazing viral videos. Nothing snags your attention like seeing people hanging out on floating couches being served up delicious tacos in the middle of a bay in the Caribbean. You see it, and you instantly start dreaming of being there. Admit it: It happened to you, too. ;) So if you’ve got a trip planned to the USVI and are wondering if you should add a trip to Lime Out to your itinerary (short answer: definitely yes ), then here’s everything you need to know.
Show More