Renting vs Chartering a Boat for the Day in the Virgin Islands

April 20, 2023
A man and a woman are swimming in the ocean on a boat.

When staying in the US Virgin Islands, whether you’re on St. Thomas or St. John, you’re surrounded by other islands you’re going to want to explore. Between the USVI and BVI, there are countless snorkel spots, beach bars, and other iconic locales. This is why the region is known as a boater’s paradise. You can hop on a boat for the day and island hop, easily seeing several different stops within the daylight hours.


If you’d like to go boating, the first question to determine is whether you’d like to rent a boat or charter a boat. In general, our recommendation is always to charter a boat whenever you can. In fact, all of the boat trips on our website are charters. Here’s why:


  • When you charter a boat, it comes with a Captain (and sometimes crew) who knows the boat. They will be familiar with how to operate it, how it has been maintained, and where all of the necessary equipment is located.
  • When you charter a boat, your Captain is also knowledgeable about the region. This means that they will not only know where to avoid hazardous conditions (you won’t get stuck on a reef!), but they also know fun stops and cool secret spots to explore.
  • When you charter a boat, no one in your group needs to worry about being the designated driver. Everyone can imbibe all the Painkillers and Bushwackers they desire without jeopardizing the safety of the passengers or the boat.
A boat is going through a body of water with mountains in the background
  • When you charter a boat, there is always someone to stay with the boat, if need be. Whether there’s limited space at a dock, not enough mooring balls, or everyone wants to snorkel to shore, your Captain can stay with the boat while you all continue the fun.
  • When you charter a boat, there are typically more amenities that come with it than a bareboat rental. That means you may have access to snorkel gear, floats, coolers, and more. Check out the charter boat options to see which boats offer which amenities.


Renting a boat is definitely an option if you’re familiar with the area and have boating experience. However, even with that in mind, chartering a boat with a captain allows everyone onboard to have a safe, positive, stress-free experience for the day.

You May Also Like


Three people are in a yellow ocean kayak

Cas Cay Kayak, Hike & Snorkeling Ecotour

A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. Thomas

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

3 Hours

Embark on an exclusive morning adventure through the serene beauty of Cas Cay, where tranquil mangroves, vibrant marine life, and breathtaking volcanic vistas await—discover this hidden gem with knowledgeable guides.

A group of people are walking down a path towards the ocean.
A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. John

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

3 Hours

Hike & Beach Adventure Tour: Discover Honeymoon Beach on St. John

Looking to pack a BIG experience into a short amount of time? Then we’ve got just the adventure for you! This tour is designed for groups of 4 or more.

A group of people are swimming with sea turtles in the ocean.

Swim alongside graceful Hawksbill and Green Sea Turtles in the crystal-clear waters of St. Croix on this unforgettable guided snorkel tour. Explore vibrant coral reefs and encounter diverse marine life with expert guides ensuring a safe and memorable experience. Perfect for all skill levels, this unique adventure offers an up-close look at St. Croix’s stunning underwater world—an experience you’ll never forget.

A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

St. Croix

A black and white hourglass icon on a white background.

1.5 Hours

St. Croix's Best Snorkeling with Sea Turtles

Other Blogs


By Chrissann Nickel August 27, 2026
For many people, their vacation in the US Virgin Islands is the first time they’ve gotten the opportunity to try stand up paddle boarding (also known as “SUP”). And while many of them arrive just a little intimidated at first, it ends up being one of the most fun experiences of their trip. If you, too, aren’t sure if paddle boarding in the USVI is for you, we’d like to encourage you to give it a shot. You’ve got this! We have stand up paddle boards available for rent on all three islands: St. Thomas , St. John , and St. Croix . With a SUP rental in the VI, you have endless opportunities to explore and to spend quality time in our gorgeous Caribbean waters. Your SUP rental opens up a world of adventure for you. Here are some answers to the frequently asked questions we get regarding stand up paddle boarding in the Virgin Islands to set your mind at ease:
Blue snorkeling mask and snorkel resting on a rocky shore by the water
By Chrissann Nickel July 30, 2026
What was that?! USVI underwater mysteries solved: anemones, flamingo tongue snails, sea hares, white urchins, and reef squid explained by our guides.
Child watching a small frog resting on an outstretched hand outdoors in sunlight
By Chrissann Nickel June 29, 2026
8 fun Virgin Islands nature facts for kids: sea turtles, pelicans, mongoose, mangroves, and more wild facts to explore on your USVI family trip.
A large body of water with boats in it and a city in the background
June 26, 2026
Things to do in St. John: top Virgin Islands National Park hikes, beaches, snorkeling spots, cultural sites, and dining, for families, couples, and explorers.
White sandy beach with turquoise water, palm trees, and a bright blue sky with clouds
June 25, 2026
Trying to choose between a kayak tour and a snorkel tour in the Virgin Islands? Compare effort, cost, and what you'll see to pick the right adventure.
learn how to kayak USVI
By Chrissann Nickel June 23, 2026
Planning a Virgin Islands trip? Learn how to paddle a kayak properly as a beginner, from grip and posture to the 3 basic strokes, before you go.
Turquoise tropical bay with sandy beach, green hillside, and clear blue sky
June 23, 2026
Hurricane season in St. Thomas runs June–November, peaking Aug–Oct. Here's what to know about timing, risk, and whether to still book your trip.
Sunny stone steps between old arched buildings, with palm trees and a few people walking in the plaza.
By Chrissann Nickel May 25, 2026
Our 6 favorite St. John souvenirs to shop in Mongoose Junction: rash guards, hook bracelets, sail bags, wind chimes, and more island keepsakes.
People walking along a sandy forest trail surrounded by dense green trees
By Chrissann Nickel April 27, 2026
Our top 10 hiking tips for the USVI: sun protection, hydration, footwear, timing, and safety advice for exploring St. Thomas, St. John, and St. Croix.
Show More